I spent a day at Semrush's AI search bootcamp earlier this week. The most useful thing in it was not a tactic, it was a number, and the number is awkward if you sell websites.
McKinsey puts the share of sources AI search pulls from a brand's own site at five to ten per cent. A separate analysis by AirOps and Kevin Indig puts earned, third-party sources at 84 per cent of AI citations. The two do not agree precisely and they do not need to. Both say the same thing: when an AI assistant describes your business, most of what it is reading was written by somebody else.
That reorders the job. Here is what the day covered, what the research behind it actually says, and the five things I would change on Monday.
Is your own website still worth anything?
Yes, and the framing I will be stealing is this: your website is the source of truth, everything else is the evidence.
Somebody told a story about hunting for a Vienna restaurant that could seat twelve for a family party. They asked an assistant, got a shortlist, then went and worked out why those restaurants. Each one had a page on its own site saying plainly that it suits large groups and celebrations. And each one had Google reviews from customers saying the same thing back.
The site made the claim. Other people corroborated it. That pairing is what got recommended.
Nothing corroborates a claim you never made. So the site still matters enormously, it just stopped being the place the work finishes.
Why does ranking well no longer get you quoted?
This was the figure that landed hardest in the room, and it is the one I would put in front of anybody still reporting positions.
Between 8 and 12 per cent of pages that rank well in normal search show up in AI answers. That is from Semrush's own AI Visibility Index. Holding the top spot does not get you cited.
It fits what we already published using our own data: we have a glossary page that ranks 3.3 for its main term and took 2,695 impressions across all its queries last month with no clicks at all. We wrote that up here. Ranking is an input. It stopped being the outcome.
There is a reason underneath it, and it is structural rather than a quirk.
What actually happens when someone asks a question?
Three things, and the middle one is the part most people have not internalised.
The question becomes several questions. Type "best help desk for e-commerce" and the system does not go looking for that phrase. It breaks the question into separate searches, none of which is the question anyone asked. This is query fan-out. Your content is not competing once, it is competing several times, against several different sets of pages, and it only takes one branch to pull a competitor in.
It retrieves passages, not pages. Google asks which pages to list. An assistant asks which passages to use. That is a different unit of work, and it means a brilliant page with its point buried two thirds of the way down loses to a worse page that answers in its first paragraph.
Kevin Indig's analysis of 1.2 million AI responses found 44.2 per cent of AI citations come from the top third of a document. Whatever gets lifted has to make sense on its own, because that is how it gets read.
If you are not retrieved, nothing downstream saves you. No amount of quality in the answer matters if the passage never reached the model.
Two practical consequences. Put the answer at the top of the page, which is the first line of our page spec and now has a number behind it. And make sure the content is actually reachable, which means checking what a crawler can read rather than assuming.
The bootcamp set the same homework we give clients: open your most important page, turn JavaScript off, reload it, and see whether the headings, body text and prices are still there.
Does AI describe your business the way you describe it?
Probably not exactly, and the gap is measurable.
The example used was Notion, and it is one you can reproduce in a minute. Their homepage describes agentic software for productivity. Ask ChatGPT and you get an all-in-one productivity and collaboration app. Notion did not make a mistake. They changed their positioning on their own site, and that stopped being enough on its own.
The reason is that models do not read your pages and take your word for it. They build an understanding of what your brand is from everything published about you, weigh which description is most corroborated, and repeat that. Change your site and you have changed one input.
The version worth running on yourself is simpler. Read how you are described on your own website, your LinkedIn page, your Google Business Profile, any directory you are listed in and whatever review platform covers your sector. Those descriptions were written by different people at different times and they drift. Something has to decide which one is authoritative, and it will not ask you.
There is a decent survey figure on how much attention this gets. Contentful's State of Marketing Agents survey from September 2026 found 83 per cent of marketing leaders call accurate AI representation a top priority, and 24 per cent actually audit what AI says about them.
That gap is the cheapest work on this entire list. Ask an assistant what your company does. Then ask what it sells, who it is for, and what it costs. It takes ten minutes.
What makes AI recommend you rather than hedge?
Hedging is the word I took away. "Some users report." "However, reviews suggest." "It depends on your needs." That is a model declining to commit, and it is measurable. Track the phrases over time and you have a trend.
The example underneath it is the most alarming thing I saw all day, and it is about an agency rather than a client. It is also published, so you can read it yourself.
Seer Interactive asked AI what people say about working with them. The answer: most mentioned high account manager turnover. They traced it to one negative review from 2018 on an agency-review site, which the model weighted above dozens of positive reviews and client quotes. The same study found AI declined to answer prompts about their brand 31 per cent of the time.
One stale review, outweighing everything. That is not a reason to panic, it is a reason to know what is out there before a prospect does.
It also sharpens something we already argue. A star rating gives a model nothing to quote. A review naming who the customer is, what they used it for and what the outcome was gives it something concrete to attribute. We wrote about why the sentences matter more than the stars earlier this year, and this is the mechanism behind it.
How do you measure any of this honestly?
Carefully, and not with one number.
Ask an assistant the same question twice and you will often get two answers. Ask from another account and you probably will. So a screenshot is a screenshot, and a single visibility score implies a stability that is not there.
The method we use and would defend: fix a set of real buyer questions, ask each several times on a schedule, count how often you appear, turn that into a frequency rather than a position, and watch the trend across a month. Report it as an observation. We published that before the bootcamp rather than after it, and nothing on the day changed my mind.
One refinement I am taking away: being mentioned and being cited are different things, and worth counting separately. You can be named in an answer without your site being read at all.
What I would change on Monday
- Ask an assistant what your business does, sells, and charges. Write down what it gets wrong. Ten minutes, and most people have never done it.
- Check how you are described across your own surfaces. Website, LinkedIn, Google Business Profile, any directory or review platform you are listed on. If they disagree, something else is deciding which version is true.
- Move the answer to the top of your most important pages. The top third of a document is where the citations come from.
- Find the five sources your industry's answers keep citing, and work out who to approach. Not fifty. Five.
- Fix your questions and ask them repeatedly, so in three months you have a trend rather than a screenshot.
What I am still unsure about
Whether any of these proportions hold for a small local business. The research is drawn heavily from software, media and large consumer brands, which are exactly the businesses with Reddit threads, listicles and review platforms written about them. A Bristol trade with none of that may well be mostly its own site by default, which would invert the advice.
Nobody asked, and I should have.
My working answer for smaller businesses is that reviews are the one third-party source almost anyone can build, and the Seer story is the reason to look at what yours already say.
What proportion of AI answer sources come from a brand's own website?
McKinsey puts it at five to ten per cent. A separate analysis by AirOps and Kevin Indig puts earned third-party sources at 84 per cent of citations, which implies a slightly larger share for owned sites. The exact number is unsettled. The direction is not: your own site is a minority of what gets read about you.
If my website is a minority of sources, does it still matter?
Yes. It is where you state plainly what you are, what you sell and what it costs, so that everything else can corroborate it. Nothing corroborates a claim you never made.
Does ranking first in Google get me cited by AI?
No. Semrush's AI Visibility Index puts the share of well-ranking pages that appear in AI answers at between 8 and 12 per cent. Ranking is an input to being cited, not the same thing as it.
What is query fan-out?
The system breaks your question into several separate searches and answers from what all of them return. It means your content competes several times over, against different sets of pages, for a question nobody typed.
Why does AI hedge about some brands?
Because the evidence it found did not pass its threshold for committing. Phrases like "some users report" or "it depends on your needs" are the signal. It is worth tracking over time, since it moves as the evidence about you changes.
Do star ratings help?
Less than you would hope. A rating is a number and cannot be quoted. A review naming the customer, what they used it for and the outcome gives a model something concrete to repeat.
Which third-party sites should I care about?
The small group that keeps appearing as a source for the questions your buyers actually ask. It differs by industry, region and platform, and it is usually not your competitor set, so it is worth checking rather than assuming.
What should a small business do first?
Ask an assistant what you do and sell, and write down what it gets wrong. Then make sure your own site states the correct version plainly. Everything else depends on that being true first. If you want to know what AI assistants are currently saying about your business, and where they are getting it, that is a short conversation. [Book a discovery call](/discovery-call).